Cats & Dogs
Best Carpet Extractors for Pet Urine and Stains (2026)
Bissell's Big Green Pet Pro at $459.99 is the machine to buy for whole-room pet urine — an 8-row brush and 1.75-gallon tanks on both sides, with the pet tool and pet formula in the box. This guide covers full-size extractors only; the compact spot-cleaner tier lives in our urine-odor protocol. And one thing no listing tells you: none of these machines heats its own water, which is exactly why they are safe to use on urine when a true steam cleaner is not.
By Nick Miles · Updated August 16, 2026 · 14 min read
PetPalHQ is reader-supported. We may earn a commission from qualifying Amazon purchases at no extra cost to you.

Evidence at a Glance
BISSELL Big Green Pet Pro Carpet Cleaner
The only pick that ships the pet upholstery tool and pet formula in the box, on Bissell's full-size 8-row XL DirtLifter chassis with 1.75-gallon tanks on both sides.
Sources: BISSELL Big Green Pet Pro 3288 specification page, Amazon Creators API listing B09XFH7B5S
Verified Aug 16, 2026
BISSELL Big Green Professional Carpet Cleaner
Bissell publishes a 5-year limited warranty on this model — the longest published term of any full-size Big Green in this guide — on the same 12-amp, 10.5-inch, 8-row chassis.
Sources: BISSELL Big Green Machine Professional 86T3 specification page, Amazon Creators API listing B00450U6CS
Verified Aug 16, 2026
BISSELL BigGreen Commercial BG10 Deep Cleaning 2 Motor Extractor
Two motors, 103-inch water lift, a 26 psi pump and a 2-gallon recovery tank — and the only machine here whose maker states it cleans forward and back.
Sources: BISSELL BigGreen Commercial BG10-KIT specification sheet, Amazon Creators API listing B00667H8CE
Verified Aug 16, 2026
BISSELL ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus Carpet Cleaner, 3588F
17.5 pounds against 42 to 44 for the Big Green machines, with a 12-row dual brush and a published 5-year limited warranty.
Sources: BISSELL ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus 3588F specification page, Amazon Creators API listing B0B94P5LDK
Verified Aug 16, 2026
Hoover Power Scrub Deluxe Carpet Cleaner Machine
The widest cleaning path in this guide at 11.25 inches, on 360-degree counter-rotating brushes, for the lowest price.
Sources: Hoover Power Scrub Deluxe specification page, Amazon Creators API listing B009ZJ2M7G
Verified Aug 16, 2026
Our Picks

Bissell
BISSELL Big Green Pet Pro Carpet Cleaner, XL DirtLifter PowerBrush
9.2 / 10
- 8-row XL DirtLifter PowerBrush across a 10.5-inch cleaning path
- 1.75-gallon clean tank and 1.75-gallon dirty tank — the largest matched pair in this guide
- 12-amp power rating with a 25-foot cord and a 9-foot hose
- Ships with a 2-in-1 pet upholstery tool and a bonus 48 oz bottle of Pet Pro Oxy urine eliminator formula
$459.99

Bissell
BISSELL Big Green Professional Carpet Cleaner, XL DirtLifter PowerBrush
9.0 / 10
- Bissell publishes a 5-year limited warranty on this model — the longest published term of any full-size Big Green here
- 8-row XL DirtLifter PowerBrush on the same 10.5-inch cleaning path as the Pet Pro
- 1.75-gallon clean tank; 12-amp power rating; 25-foot cord; 9-foot hose
- 42 pounds, two pounds lighter than the Pet Pro
$429.00

Bissell Commercial
BISSELL BigGreen Commercial BG10 Deep Cleaning 2 Motor Extractor Machine
8.8 / 10
- Two motors and a DirtLifter power brush, with a 103-inch water lift and a 26 psi pump
- 2-gallon recovery tank against a 1.75-gallon solution tank — the only pick here with more recovery than solution capacity
- The only machine in this guide whose maker states it cleans forward and back
- 25-foot cord for a stated 50-foot cleaning reach; 10-inch cleaning path; 12 amps; 42 pounds
$524.29

Bissell
BISSELL ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus Carpet Cleaner, 3588F
8.7 / 10
- 17.5 pounds against 42 to 44 for the Big Green machines — the lightest full-size upright here
- 12-row dual DirtLifter PowerBrush across an 11-inch cleaning path
- 5-year limited warranty published by Bissell
- CleanShot pretreater built in, plus a 2-in-1 pet upholstery tool, a 3-inch tough stain tool and an 8-foot hose
$237.97

Hoover
Hoover Power Scrub Deluxe Carpet Cleaner Machine, Pet & Upholstery Tools
8.2 / 10
- 11.25-inch cleaning path — the widest in this guide
- Patented 360-degree counter-rotating SpinScrub brushes; the Amazon listing specifies five of them
- 1-gallon clean tank and 1-gallon dirty tank, plus a separate 16-ounce detergent tank with Auto Mix
- 10-amp motor, 8-foot hose, 20-foot cord, 18.1 pounds
$169.99
The Short Answer
Buy the Bissell Big Green Pet Pro at $459.99. It is the full-size machine built for this exact job — an 8-row XL DirtLifter brush, 1.75-gallon tanks on both the clean and dirty sides, a 10.5-inch cleaning path, and a 9-foot hose, with the pet upholstery tool and pet formula included rather than sold separately. If you do not need the pet tooling, the near-identical Big Green Professional at $429.00 runs the same 12-amp, 10.5-inch, 8-row chassis for $30.99 less and is the only full-size Big Green whose warranty term Bissell actually publishes: five years. Buy the BigGreen Commercial BG10 at $524.90 instead if recovery is what you care about most — two motors, a 103-inch water lift, a 26 psi pump, and a 2-gallon recovery tank, and the only machine here Bissell says cleans forward and back. Every pick is a full-size upright. Compact spot cleaners are a different tier and a different job, and our urine-odor protocol covers them. One thing worth knowing before you fill the tank: none of these machines heats its own water.
Every product on this list has been scored against the PetPal Gear Score, a weighted composite of expert consensus, observed effectiveness, animal safety, long-term durability, and value. Review method: Editorial synthesis of the IICRC's published consumer guidance on carpet care and animal stains (including the two ANSI/IICRC S100 passages the IICRC quotes in its own consumer tip sheet), Humane World for Animals and ASPCA pet-cleanup protocols, VCA Animal Hospitals house-soiling guidance, and Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America allergen guidance — paired with manufacturer specification pages fetched directly from Bissell, Bissell BigGreen Commercial, and Hoover, and live listing data pulled per product through the Amazon Creators API. PetPalHQ does not operate a carpet-cleaning test lab, and no score below is a measurement.. Synthesized from 5+ expert sources.
A carpet extractor is a machine that lays down water and cleaning solution, agitates it into the carpet with a powered brush, and then pulls it back out again. That last step is the entire point, and it is the step a mop, a rag, or a bottle of spray cannot do at all. For pet owners the distinction matters more than it does for anyone else, because the problem with urine is not on the surface where you can see it.
The IICRC — the body that certifies professional carpet cleaners — puts the mechanism plainly in its consumer guidance. Writing about musty and returning odors, it notes that in many cases the source comes from the backing of the carpet or other subfloor surfaces, which cannot be removed by cleaning the surface fibers of the carpet. It adds that homeowners often do not realise absorbent carpet padding can stay wet for an extended amount of time even when the surface fibers feel dry. Then comes the sentence every pet owner has lived: if the area becomes damp again or there is high humidity in the air, you may notice the odor returns. The IICRC's own quotation of the ANSI/IICRC S100 standard says the same thing from the other direction — elevated heat and humidity created from the cleaning process can amplify odors, so they are more evident during and after cleaning and during warm, humid conditions.
That is why this guide is about recovery, not about scrubbing. And it is why we have drawn a hard line around what belongs on this page.
What this guide covers, and what it does not
This guide covers full-size upright extractors only — machines you push across a room, with a powered brush and separate clean and dirty tanks. It deliberately excludes the compact spot-cleaner tier: the portable handheld and canister machines built for one accident in one place. That is not an arbitrary split. Bissell draws the same line in its own buying guide, describing portables as machines to clean accidental spills and stains quickly from anywhere — including stairs, upholstery, and your car — while stating they are not ideal for cleaning wall-to-wall carpets.
The spot tier has its own home on this site. Our How to Get Rid of Dog & Cat Urine Smell Permanently guide is the removal protocol: finding every deposit under a UV light, the saturate-and-dwell enzyme method, and the compact extractor that belongs to that workflow. If your problem is one spot, start there and do not buy anything on this page. If your problem is a room — or a rental deposit, or a house you are about to sell, or a dog who was sick on the landing and the stairs and the hallway — you are in the right place.
The heat question, which most buying guides get wrong
Here is the piece of advice that turns up in every pet-cleaning article, and it is worth understanding precisely because it is half-right. Humane World for Animals states it directly: avoid using steam cleaners to clean urine odors from carpet or upholstery, because the heat will permanently set the stain and the odor by bonding the protein into any man-made fibers.
That warning is real, and it is about steam cleaners. None of the five machines in this guide is a steam cleaner, and none of them heats its own water. Bissell's BigGreen Commercial specification for the BG10 lists "Heater: No" outright. Bissell states that the ProHeat's HeatWave Technology helps maintain the water temperature throughout the cleaning process by using the motor's heat, and that it does not heat the water itself. Hoover's HeatForce applies hot air to the floor to speed drying, not heat to the water in the tank.
The practical consequence is a one-line rule that no product page will give you: on a urine spot, fill the tank with cool or lukewarm water, not hot. These machines will happily deliver whatever temperature you pour in, and the temperature is your decision, not the machine's. That single choice is the difference between the Humane World warning applying to you and not applying to you.
One honest complication, because pretending it away would be dishonest: the Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America gives the opposite-sounding advice for a different problem, recommending that if you are going to use carpet, select one with a low pile and steam clean it often, and that wall-to-wall carpet be removed or steam cleaned in a home someone is allergic to pets in. These two authorities are not contradicting each other so much as optimising for different outcomes — Humane World is trying to stop a stain setting and a cat re-marking the spot; the AAFA is trying to lower the allergen load in the room. If you have both problems, treat the urine deposits cool first, and save any heat for general allergen cleaning on carpet that has never been soiled.
The rinse pass almost nobody does
The other thing worth learning before you buy is that the last pass should be plain water. The IICRC repeats the instruction throughout its consumer guidance: if you own a home spotting or carpet cleaning machine, rinse the area with clear water only after no evidence of the stain remains.
The reason is soil, not chemistry. Under its Rapid Re-soiling heading, the IICRC lists detergent or soap residues not effectively rinsed during the cleaning process first among the causes, and adds that excessive soap residue left behind from untrained cleaners or DIY homeowner attempts is another. Elsewhere it explains the mechanism: products containing surfactants or detergents will attract soil to the area if not thoroughly rinsed, and over time new soil will stick to the residue, creating a dark area. There is also a warranty-grade version of the same warning — some disinfectants and oxy products may cause discoloration of textile furnishings and carpet if not fully rinsed and neutralized.
So the sequence that actually works is four steps, and only two of them involve the machine: blot and extract what is fresh, apply an enzymatic cleaner and let it dwell, extract the cleaner with the machine, then run one more pass with clear water only. The ASPCA names the chemistry for step two — clean accidents thoroughly with an enzymatic cleanser designed to neutralize pet odors — and adds a warning worth taping to the bottle: do not clean up accidents with an ammonia-based cleanser, because urine contains ammonia and cleaning with ammonia could attract your cat to the same spot to urinate again.

$459.99
- 8-row XL DirtLifter PowerBrush across a 10.5-inch cleaning path
- 1.75-gallon clean tank and 1.75-gallon dirty tank — the largest matched pair in this guide
- 12-amp power rating with a 25-foot cord and a 9-foot hose
- Ships with a 2-in-1 pet upholstery tool and a bonus 48 oz bottle of Pet Pro Oxy urine eliminator formula
- 44 pounds — a machine you park and pull, not one you carry upstairs
This is the machine most people cleaning up after a dog or a cat should buy, and the reason is unglamorous: it is the full-size Big Green chassis with the pet accessories already in the box. Bissell's own specification page lists a 12-amp motor, a 10.5-inch cleaning path, an 8-row XL DirtLifter PowerBrush, a 9-foot hose, and — the number that matters most for a whole-room job — 1.75 gallons of capacity on both the clean and the dirty side. Nothing else in this guide matches on both tanks at once. On a full-room pet accident, the constraint is almost never scrubbing power. It is how many times you have to walk to the sink.
The pet tooling is the rest of the argument. The listing ships a 2-in-1 pet upholstery tool and a 48-ounce bottle of Pet Pro Oxy urine eliminator, which is the difference between starting work the day the box arrives and placing a second order. That matters more than it sounds, because the sequence that actually works on urine is a chemical step followed by an extraction step. The ASPCA's guidance on litter-box problems is direct about the chemical half: clean accidents thoroughly with an enzymatic cleanser designed to neutralize pet odors. The IICRC's consumer guidance covers the other half, telling homeowners to use a wet vacuum to extract the spotting and rinsing agents — and warning that some disinfectants and oxy products may cause discoloration of textile furnishings and carpet if not fully rinsed and neutralized. A machine with a big recovery tank is how you finish the second half properly.
Here is the honest trade-off, and it is a real one. Bissell does not publish a warranty term on this model's page. The Big Green Professional below — same 12 amps, same 10.5-inch path, same 8-row XL DirtLifter — publishes five years, and costs $30.99 less. What the extra $30.99 buys on the Pet Pro is the pet tool and the pet formula, not a stronger machine. If you would rather have the published warranty and buy your own enzyme cleaner, that is a defensible call, and we would not argue with it. Two more things this machine cannot do: at 44 pounds it is not a stairs machine, and it does not heat its own water — see the section below on why that second point is a feature on urine, not a shortcoming.
What We Love
- 1.75 gallons on both the clean and the dirty tank — no other pick in this guide matches on both
- 8-row XL DirtLifter PowerBrush on a 10.5-inch path, per Bissell's published specification
- Pet upholstery tool and a 48 oz bottle of Pet Pro Oxy urine formula included, not sold separately
- 12 amps with a 25-foot cord and a 9-foot hose — enough reach to do a room without moving the machine
- Sold by Amazon.com itself at time of check, not by a third-party marketplace seller
What Could Be Better
- Bissell does not publish a warranty term for this model — the near-identical Professional publishes five years
- Costs $30.99 more than the Professional for what is, on the published specs, the same cleaning hardware plus accessories
- At 44 pounds it is a park-and-pull machine, not something to carry up a flight of stairs
- Does not heat its own water, so a hot-water cleaning step depends entirely on what you pour into the tank
The Verdict
Get the Big Green Pet Pro if you want one machine to handle whole-room pet accidents and you would rather have the pet tool and the pet formula in the box than an extra $30.99 and a published warranty term.
Sources
- BISSELL (Big Green Pet Pro specification page): Power Rating: 12 Amps; Power Cord Length: 25'; Hose Length: 9'; Cleaning Path Width: 10.5"; Clean Tank Capacity: 1.75 Gal; Dirty Tank Capacity: 1.75 Gal; Weight: 44 lbs; 8-Row DirtLifter PowerBrush
- IICRC (Consumer Floor and Furnishings Care Information, section 14, Animal Stains and Odors): "Use a wet/dry vacuum for the initial pick-up of urine and loose feces and to extract spotting and rinsing agents."
- Amazon Creators API (live listing): Listed at $459.99, availability IN_STOCK, condition New, sold from the Amazon.com buy box at time of check

$429.00
- Bissell publishes a 5-year limited warranty on this model — the longest published term of any full-size Big Green here
- 8-row XL DirtLifter PowerBrush on the same 10.5-inch cleaning path as the Pet Pro
- 1.75-gallon clean tank; 12-amp power rating; 25-foot cord; 9-foot hose
- 42 pounds, two pounds lighter than the Pet Pro
- Cleans on the forward and the backward pass, per the product listing, reducing cleaning time
Read the two Bissell specification pages side by side and the value case makes itself. The Professional and the Pet Pro both list a 12-amp motor, a 10.5-inch cleaning path, an 8-row XL DirtLifter PowerBrush, a 9-foot hose, a 25-foot cord, and a 1.75-gallon clean tank. The Professional weighs two pounds less and costs $30.99 less. And it carries something the Pet Pro's page does not: a stated 5-year limited warranty. On a machine with two pumps, a brush motor and a suction motor, a published five-year term is not a rounding detail.
What you give up is the pet layer, and you should be clear-eyed about it. There is no pet upholstery tool in this box and no bottle of pet formula. You will buy an enzymatic cleaner separately — which, to be fair, most people cleaning up after a cat end up doing anyway. VCA Animal Hospitals names the category directly in its guidance on inappropriate elimination, recommending an enzymatic cleaner to remove residual odors that could encourage a cat to return to previously soiled areas. That product is bought by the bottle regardless of which machine is pushing it into the carpet.
One spec is genuinely missing here, and we would rather flag it than paper over it: Bissell states the 1.75-gallon clean tank on this page but does not publish the dirty-tank capacity, which it does publish for the Pet Pro. The two-tank design is confirmed in Bissell's own copy — the tanks keep the dirty water separate from the clean water and solution — but the recovery number is not on the page. If matched 1.75-gallon capacity on both sides is the thing you are buying, the Pet Pro is the model that puts that figure in writing.
What We Love
- 5-year limited warranty published by Bissell — the longest published term of any full-size Big Green here
- Same 12 amps, 10.5-inch path and 8-row XL DirtLifter as the Pet Pro, for $30.99 less
- 1.75-gallon clean tank with a confirmed separated two-tank design
- Listing states it cleans on both the forward and backward pass, reducing cleaning time
- 42 pounds — marginally easier to move than the Pet Pro
What Could Be Better
- No pet upholstery tool and no pet formula in the box — both are separate purchases
- Bissell does not publish this model's dirty-tank capacity, only the clean side
- Still a 42-pound full-size upright, with the same stairs problem as the Pet Pro
- Does not heat its own water
The Verdict
Get the Big Green Professional if the published 5-year warranty matters more to you than a pet tool and a bottle of formula — it is the same cleaning hardware for less money.
Sources
- BISSELL (Big Green Machine Professional 86T3 specification page): Limited warranty: 5 years; Power Rating: 12 amps; Cleaning Path Width: 10.5"; Clean Tank Capacity: 1.75 gallons; Hose Length: 9'; Power Cord Length: 25'; Weight: 42 lbs; 8-Row XL DirtLifter PowerBrush
- BISSELL (Big Green Machine Professional 86T3 product page, two-tank description): "Clean longer without the need for refills thanks to the two large-capacity tanks that keep the dirty water separate from the clean water and solution."
- Amazon Creators API (live listing): Listed at $429.00, availability IN_STOCK, condition New, Amazon.com buy box at time of check; listing states tank capacity 1.75 gallons and a 12-amp power rating

$524.29
- Two motors and a DirtLifter power brush, with a 103-inch water lift and a 26 psi pump
- 2-gallon recovery tank against a 1.75-gallon solution tank — the only pick here with more recovery than solution capacity
- The only machine in this guide whose maker states it cleans forward and back
- 25-foot cord for a stated 50-foot cleaning reach; 10-inch cleaning path; 12 amps; 42 pounds
- 1-year limited commercial warranty — the shortest published term in this guide
Every other machine in this guide is a consumer product with a commercial-sounding name. This one is the actual commercial unit, and it is built around a different priority: getting liquid back out of the carpet. Bissell's BigGreen Commercial spec sheet lists two motors, a 26 psi pump, a 103-inch water lift, and — the detail worth the money — a 2-gallon recovery tank against a 1.75-gallon solution tank. It is the only pick here that can take back more than it puts down. The same sheet is also the only manufacturer document in this guide that says the machine cleans forward and back, which halves the number of passes a wet section needs.
Recovery is the right thing to optimise for on urine specifically, and the IICRC's consumer guidance explains why better than any marketing page. Odor returns, the IICRC says, when the area becomes damp again or humidity rises — and it notes this can happen even after professional cleaning, when moisture reactivates the odor. The IICRC also lists over-wetting from improper cleaning as a cause of carpet rippling. Both failure modes are moisture that stayed behind. A 103-inch water lift and a 2-gallon recovery tank are the specifications that address them directly.
The trade-offs are real and you should weigh them properly. The warranty is 1 year limited commercial, against the five years Bissell publishes on the Professional and the ProHeat — the shortest term in this guide on the most expensive machine. The cleaning path is 10 inches, the narrowest here, so a large room takes more passes. There is no pet upholstery tool and no pet formula. And the brush specification does not map cleanly onto the consumer line: Bissell publishes "Brush: 2 Rows Rotating" for this machine against an 8-row XL DirtLifter on the consumer Big Greens, and it does not publish any comparison between the two lines — different product families, different spec conventions, and we are not going to invent a translation between them. Buy this one for suction and recovery, which are documented, not for a brush advantage, which is not.
What We Love
- 2-gallon recovery tank against a 1.75-gallon solution tank — the only pick here that recovers more than it lays down
- 103-inch water lift and a 26 psi pump, both published by Bissell
- Two motors rather than one shared between suction and brush drive
- The only machine in this guide its maker states cleans forward and back
- 25-foot cord for a stated 50-foot cleaning reach, at 42 pounds
What Could Be Better
- 1-year limited commercial warranty — the shortest published term here, on the most expensive machine
- 10-inch cleaning path is the narrowest in this guide, so a large room takes more passes
- No pet upholstery tool and no pet formula included
- Bissell publishes a 2-row rotating brush for this line against 8-row XL DirtLifter on the consumer machines, and publishes no comparison between the conventions
- Bissell does not publish a hose length for this model on its spec sheet or product page
The Verdict
Get the BG10 if pulling moisture back out is the specification you care about most and you can live with a 1-year warranty and a 10-inch path to get it.
Sources
- BISSELL BigGreen Commercial (BG10-KIT specification sheet): "2 motors and DirtLifter power brush • Motor amperage 12 • 2 large capacity tanks • 1.75-gallon solution tack • 2-gallon recovery tank • Pump pressure 26 psi • Water Lift 103" • 10" cleaning path"; "Cleans forward and back"; "Weighs 42 lbs"; "1 Year Limited Waranty"
- BISSELL BigGreen Commercial (BG10 product page): "Brush: 2 Rows Rotating"; "Warranty: Limited 1 year commercial warranty"; "Water Lift: 103""; "Power rating: 12 amps"; "Heater: No"
- IICRC (Consumer Floor and Furnishings Care Information, section 13, on odor return): "If the area becomes damp again or there is high humidity in the air, you may notice the odor returns. This can also occur when an affected area has been professionally cleaned, and moisture/steam reactivates the odor."

$237.97
- 17.5 pounds against 42 to 44 for the Big Green machines — the lightest full-size upright here
- 12-row dual DirtLifter PowerBrush across an 11-inch cleaning path
- 5-year limited warranty published by Bissell
- CleanShot pretreater built in, plus a 2-in-1 pet upholstery tool, a 3-inch tough stain tool and an 8-foot hose
- 1-gallon clean tank; 6.8-amp power rating; 25-foot cord
The Big Green machines weigh 42 and 44 pounds. This one weighs 17.5. If the accidents in your house happen on a staircase, in an upstairs bedroom, or across several rooms on different floors, that single number outranks every other specification in this guide, because the best machine is the one you will actually drag out on a Tuesday night. Bissell pairs that weight with an 11-inch cleaning path — wider than either Big Green's 10.5 inches — a 12-row dual DirtLifter PowerBrush, and a published 5-year limited warranty.
It is also the best-tooled machine here for spot work that is not quite spot-cleaner work. The CleanShot pretreater fires a targeted dose at a stain before the pass, and the box includes a 2-in-1 pet upholstery tool, a 3-inch tough stain tool and an 8-foot hose for stairs, pet beds and furniture. That covers the awkward middle ground: too big for a handheld, too small to justify hauling out a 44-pound upright.
The trade-off is endurance and raw power, and it is not subtle. The clean tank holds 1 gallon against 1.75 on the Big Greens, so you will refill more often on a whole-room job. The motor is rated 6.8 amps against 12. And Bissell does not publish a dirty-tank capacity for this model at all, which is a gap worth knowing about on a machine whose whole pitch is portability between rooms. One more thing worth reading carefully, because the marketing invites the wrong conclusion: Bissell states that HeatWave Technology helps maintain the water temperature by using the motor's heat, and that it does not heat the water itself. This is not a steam cleaner. On pet urine, that is a good thing — see below.
What We Love
- 17.5 pounds — genuinely carryable up a staircase, unlike anything else in this guide
- 11-inch cleaning path, the second widest here, on a 12-row dual DirtLifter PowerBrush
- 5-year limited warranty published by Bissell
- CleanShot pretreater plus pet upholstery tool, 3-inch stain tool and an 8-foot hose in the box
- Lowest price of the four Bissell machines here by $191.03
What Could Be Better
- 1-gallon clean tank against 1.75 on the Big Greens — more trips to the sink on a whole-room job
- 6.8-amp motor against 12 amps on every other Bissell here
- Bissell does not publish a dirty-tank capacity for this model
- HeatWave maintains water temperature rather than heating water, which the product name does not make obvious
The Verdict
Get the ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus if your accidents happen on stairs or across floors — 17.5 pounds and a 5-year warranty beat tank capacity you will never carry upstairs.
Sources
- BISSELL (ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus 3588F specification page): Power Rating: 6.8 Amps; Hose Length: 8'; Cleaning Path Width: 11"; Clean Tank Capacity: 1 Gallon; Weight: 17.5 lbs; Power Cord Length: 25'; 12 Row Dual DirtLifter PowerBrush; 5 Year Limited Warranty
- BISSELL (ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus, HeatWave description): "HeatWave Technology®, which helps maintain the water temperature throughout the cleaning process by utilizing the motor's heat. However, it does not heat the water itself."
- ASPCA (Litter Box Problems): "Clean accidents thoroughly with an enzymatic cleanser designed to neutralize pet odors." and "Do not clean up accidents with an ammonia-based cleanser. Urine contains ammonia, and therefore cleaning with ammonia could attract your cat to the same spot to urinate again."

$169.99
- 11.25-inch cleaning path — the widest in this guide
- Patented 360-degree counter-rotating SpinScrub brushes; the Amazon listing specifies five of them
- 1-gallon clean tank and 1-gallon dirty tank, plus a separate 16-ounce detergent tank with Auto Mix
- 10-amp motor, 8-foot hose, 20-foot cord, 18.1 pounds
- HeatForce applies hot air to the floor to speed drying
The cheapest machine here has the widest cleaning path in the guide. Hoover publishes 11.25 inches against 10.5 on both Big Greens and 10 on the commercial BG10, on a 10-amp motor with a matched pair of 1-gallon tanks, at 18.1 pounds. For a reader whose real question is whether to buy a machine at all rather than keep renting one, this is a sensible entry point that does not feel like a toy.
Two design details are worth calling out honestly. First, the brush action: Hoover describes patented 360-degree counter-rotating brushes that scrub carpets at all angles. That is Hoover's functional answer to the forward-and-back question, and it is a genuine design difference from a single-direction roller — though Hoover's specification page stops short of publishing a brush count, so the "five brushes" figure in this guide comes from the product listing rather than from Hoover directly. Second, the separate 16-ounce detergent tank with Auto Mix. That is a more useful feature than it looks, because it takes dilution out of your hands, and the IICRC's consumer guidance lists un-rinsed detergent residue first among the causes of rapid re-soiling, warning that surfactants will attract soil to the area if not thoroughly rinsed.
What you give up at this price is endurance and warranty. One gallon per side means frequent trips to the sink on a whole room. The cord is 20 feet against 25 on every Bissell here, so you will change outlets more often. The warranty is 2 years on the motor, against 5 on the Bissell Professional and ProHeat. And one honest note on the paperwork: Hoover's own page header and its specification table return different model suffixes for this machine, so we have described it by name and specification rather than pinning it to a model code we cannot confirm. HeatForce, for the record, applies hot air to the floor to speed drying — it does not heat the water in the tank, which is the correct behaviour for urine work.
What We Love
- 11.25-inch cleaning path — the widest in this guide, on the cheapest machine
- Matched 1-gallon clean and dirty tanks plus a separate 16-ounce detergent tank with automatic mixing
- Patented 360-degree counter-rotating brushes, Hoover's answer to single-direction rollers
- 18.1 pounds with pet, upholstery and crevice tools and an 8-foot hose included
- $60 to $355 less than everything else here
What Could Be Better
- 1 gallon per side — the shortest run between refills of any pick, tied with the ProHeat
- 2-year motor warranty against 5 years on the Bissell Professional and ProHeat
- 20-foot cord, the shortest here, against 25 feet on every Bissell
- Hoover does not publish a brush count, and its page header and specification table disagree on the model suffix
The Verdict
Get the Power Scrub Deluxe if you are replacing rental trips rather than buying a machine for life — the widest path here, at the lowest price, with the shortest warranty.
Sources
- Hoover (Power Scrub Deluxe specification page): Clean water tank 1 gallon; dirty water tank 1 gallon; detergent tank 16 ounces; Cleaning Path Width: 11.25 inches; 10 amps; Hose Length: 8 feet; Cord Length: 20 feet; Weight: 18.1 lbs; "Patented 360-degree, counter-rotating brushes scrub carpets at all angles"; warranty 2 Year(s)
- Amazon Creators API (live listing): Listed at $169.99, availability IN_STOCK, condition New, Amazon.com buy box at time of check; listing states "Five counter-rotating SpinScrub brushes" and an 8 ft hose with upholstery, pet and crevice tools
- IICRC (Consumer Floor and Furnishings Care Information, section 23, Rapid Re-soiling): "Detergent or soap residues are not effectively rinsed during the cleaning process" is listed first among the causes of re-soiling; section 6 adds that products containing surfactants "will attract soil to the area if not thoroughly rinsed. Over time, new soil will 'stick' to the residue creating a dark area."
How We Score
Formula
Extraction Capability Score = (Water Recovery & Suction × 0.30) + (Brush Coverage & Cleaning Path × 0.25) + (Tank Endurance × 0.20) + (Warranty & Build × 0.15) + (Cost per Cleaning Session × 0.10)
Score Factors
- Water Recovery & Suction · 30%
- Brush Coverage & Cleaning Path · 25%
- Tank Endurance · 20%
- Warranty & Build · 15%
- Cost per Cleaning Session · 10%
| Rank | Product | Score |
|---|---|---|
| #1 | Bissell BISSELL Big Green Pet Pro Carpet Cleaner, XL DirtLifter PowerBrush | 9.2 |
| #2 | Bissell BISSELL Big Green Professional Carpet Cleaner, XL DirtLifter PowerBrush | 9.0 |
| #3 | Bissell Commercial BISSELL BigGreen Commercial BG10 Deep Cleaning 2 Motor Extractor Machine | 8.8 |
| #4 | Bissell BISSELL ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus Carpet Cleaner, 3588F | 8.7 |
| #5 | Hoover Hoover Power Scrub Deluxe Carpet Cleaner Machine, Pet & Upholstery Tools | 8.2 |
When NOT to Buy
Skip this whole category if the job is a single fresh accident on one spot. A full-size upright is built to pull a machine across a room, and none of these five will out-perform a cloth, an enzyme cleaner and patience on a puddle you caught in the first ten minutes. Our How to Get Rid of Dog & Cat Urine Smell Permanently guide covers that job properly — the find-every-deposit-with-UV step, the saturate-and-dwell enzyme method, and the compact spot-cleaner tier this guide deliberately excludes. Bissell is blunt about the boundary in its own buying guide: portable machines are for spills and stains from anywhere including stairs, upholstery and your car, and are not ideal for cleaning wall-to-wall carpets. This guide is the wall-to-wall half. That one is the spot half.
Skip the machine entirely and call your veterinarian first if the soiling is new, sudden, or spreading. Both the ASPCA and VCA Animal Hospitals treat house-soiling as a medical question before it is a cleaning question, and no extractor fixes a urinary-tract problem. Cleaning up faster while the underlying cause goes unexamined is the most expensive version of this purchase.
Skip the upgrade if urine has soaked into the pad and stayed there. This is the limit of the category and we would rather say it than sell past it. Humane World for Animals is direct: if urine has soaked down into the padding underneath your carpet, in some cases you may need to replace portions of carpet and padding. The IICRC goes further on aged deposits, stating that it is often impossible to completely restore the original appearance of a textile furnishing damaged with aged pet urine, especially where the wrong products or methods were tried first — and that excessive pet urine is one of the named causes of delamination, the separation of a carpet's two backings. No machine on this page claims to extract urine from a carpet pad, and none of them can.
Skip the 42-to-44-pound machines if your home is vertical. A Big Green that lives in a basement because nobody wants to carry it upstairs cleans nothing. The 17.5-pound ProHeat exists for exactly this reason.
Frequently Asked Questions
- Will a carpet extractor remove urine that has soaked into the carpet pad?
- No, and no manufacturer in this guide claims it will. The IICRC is explicit that odor sources in the backing or subfloor cannot be removed by cleaning the surface fibers of the carpet, and Humane World for Animals states that where urine has soaked into the padding you may need to replace portions of carpet and padding. An extractor pulls moisture and solution out of the carpet and can reach the base of the yarns and the backing surface. It does not reach through to a saturated pad. If a spot has been soaked repeatedly over months, budget for pad replacement rather than a better machine.
- Is a carpet extractor the same thing as a steam cleaner?
- No. An extractor sprays liquid, agitates it with a brush, and vacuums it back up. A steam cleaner uses heat to generate steam. None of the machines in this guide heats its own water — Bissell publishes "Heater: No" for the BG10 and states that the ProHeat's HeatWave maintains water temperature using the motor's heat rather than heating the water itself. That distinction matters on urine, because Humane World for Animals warns that heat will permanently set the stain and odor by bonding the protein into man-made fibers. Fill these machines with cool or lukewarm water on a urine spot.
- Why does the smell come back a week after I clean the carpet?
- Because something was left behind. The IICRC gives two mechanisms. The first is moisture and depth — the source may sit in the backing or subfloor, and if the area becomes damp again or humidity rises, the odor returns, which the IICRC notes can happen even after professional cleaning when moisture reactivates it. The second is wicking, which the IICRC defines as the upward or outward migration of water-soluble materials on carpet fiber surfaces during drying: soil left at the base of the yarns and on the backing moves back to the yarn tips, where it becomes a visible stain again after the carpet dries. Both point the same way — extract more thoroughly, and dry faster.
- Do I still need an enzyme cleaner if I own an extractor?
- Yes. They do different jobs, and the machine does not replace the chemistry. The ASPCA recommends cleaning accidents thoroughly with an enzymatic cleanser designed to neutralize pet odors, and VCA Animal Hospitals recommends an enzymatic cleaner to remove residual odors that could encourage a cat to return to previously soiled areas. The machine's job is to work that cleaner into the fibers and then get it — and everything it lifted — back out. The IICRC frames extraction the same way, describing a wet vacuum as the tool used to extract spotting and rinsing agents.
- How much difference does tank size actually make?
- More than brush specifications do, on a whole-room job. Bissell's own buying guide notes that a ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro can typically handle a 10-by-12-foot room before the dirty water tank needs emptying, while a smaller TurboClean PowerBrush covers about 8 by 8 feet per fill. Scaling that up is the real argument for the 1.75-gallon Big Green tanks over the 1-gallon machines: fewer interruptions, and less temptation to stop before the rinse pass.
- Which machine should I buy if I have a puppy and a staircase?
- The ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus at $237.97. At 17.5 pounds it is the only pick here you can carry up a flight of stairs without planning the trip, it ships with an 8-foot hose and a pet upholstery tool for the stair treads themselves, and Bissell publishes a 5-year limited warranty on it. You will refill a 1-gallon tank more often than a Big Green's 1.75 gallons, which is the trade you are making.
- Does the wider cleaning path on the cheaper machines mean they clean better?
- Not on its own. A wider path covers ground faster, which is why the 11.25-inch Hoover and the 11-inch ProHeat are the quicker machines per pass. Cleaning effectiveness on urine depends much more on how much liquid comes back up, which is where the 12-amp Big Greens and the two-motor BG10 — with its published 103-inch water lift and 2-gallon recovery tank — are working from different specifications entirely. Path width is a speed number. Water lift and recovery volume are the cleaning numbers.
- Is buying a machine cheaper than renting one?
- It depends entirely on how often the accidents happen. A single rental is far cheaper than any pick here. Humane World for Animals suggests renting a carpet cleaner from a local hardware or grocery store as a reasonable option. The purchase case only builds if you are cleaning repeatedly — a dog with a medical issue, a cat in the middle of a litter-box problem, a puppy in month three of house-training — where the rental trips accumulate and the machine is available at 11pm on the night it happens.
Bottom Line
Buy the Bissell Big Green Pet Pro at $459.99 if you want one machine for whole-room pet accidents with the pet tool and pet formula already in the box — 1.75 gallons on both tanks is the largest matched pair here.
Buy the Bissell Big Green Professional at $429.00 if you would rather have the published 5-year limited warranty and buy your own enzyme cleaner — it is the same 12-amp, 10.5-inch, 8-row chassis for $30.99 less.
Buy the BigGreen Commercial BG10 at $524.90 if pulling moisture back out is your priority — 103-inch water lift, a 26 psi pump, a 2-gallon recovery tank, and the only forward-and-back claim in this guide, against a 1-year warranty.
Buy the ProHeat 2X Revolution Pet Pro Plus at $237.97 if the accidents happen on stairs or across floors — at 17.5 pounds it is the only pick here you will genuinely carry, and it still publishes a 5-year warranty.
Buy the Hoover Power Scrub Deluxe at $169.99 if you are replacing rental trips — the widest path in the guide at 11.25 inches, with the shortest warranty and the smallest tanks.
Whatever you buy, fill it with cool or warm water, not hot, on a urine spot — and buy the enzyme cleaner separately regardless of which machine you choose. The machine is the second half of the job.
Sources & Methodology
Methodology
Extraction Capability Score = (Water Recovery & Suction × 0.30) + (Brush Coverage & Cleaning Path × 0.25) + (Tank Endurance × 0.20) + (Warranty & Build × 0.15) + (Cost per Cleaning Session × 0.10)
Expert review sources
- IICRC (Institute of Inspection, Cleaning and Restoration Certification) — Consumer Floor and Furnishings Care Information, including the ANSI/IICRC S100 passages quoted therein
- Humane World for Animals (formerly The Humane Society of the United States) — How to remove pet stains and odors
- ASPCA — Litter Box Problems
- VCA Animal Hospitals — Cat Behavior Problems: House Soiling, and Inappropriate Elimination Disorders in Cats
- Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America — Pet (Dog and Cat) Allergies
Community sources
- r/CleaningTips — pet urine extraction and rinse-pass discussion
- r/dogs — whole-room accident cleanup threads
Prices and specs verified August 16, 2026.
About the author
Nick Miles is the chief editor of PetPalHQ. The picks above are editorial synthesis of manufacturer specification pages fetched directly from Bissell, Bissell BigGreen Commercial and Hoover, live Amazon listing data pulled per product through the Creators API, and published guidance from the IICRC, Humane World for Animals, the ASPCA, VCA Animal Hospitals and the AAFA. PetPalHQ does not operate a carpet-cleaning test lab. The Extraction Capability Score is a weighting of published specifications, not a measurement. Where a manufacturer does not publish a figure, this guide says so rather than filling the gap.
PetPalHQ is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program. We may earn commissions from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you.


