Gear Score Methodology
PetPal Gear Score
Best Cat Litter by Type: Clumping Clay, Plant-Based and Crystal (2026)
Editorial synthesis of litter guidance from the 2014 AAFP/ISFM Guidelines for Diagnosing and Solving House-Soiling Behavior in Cats, the ASPCA and a dvm360 review by a board-certified veterinary behaviorist, read against Amazon listing text and the World's Best, SmartCat, sWheat Scoop and PetSafe product pages, read November 15, 2026, with every price checked on Amazon November 15, 2026 for the bag size named on each card. Rankings follow the published PetPal Litter Fit Score weights. No first-hand product testing.
PetPal Litter Fit Score = (Texture & Clumping × 0.30) + (Scent × 0.25) + (Dust × 0.15) + (Odor Mechanism × 0.15) + (Tracking × 0.15)Factor breakdown
Texture & Clumping
30%How close the litter is to the AAFP/ISFM default of a fine, sand-like, clumping material, from the Amazon listing. Scoring: 10 for a clumping litter whose listing describes a fine or sand-like texture; 8 for clumping granules with no fine or sand-like description (medium grain included); 6 for a clumping litter whose item form is pellets; 3 for a non-clumping litter. Weighted highest because AAFP/ISFM says cats most commonly prefer fine-textured unscented clumping litters, and the dvm360 review reports the same early preference for fine, sand-like clumping litter.
Scent
25%Whether fragrance is added. Scoring: 10 for an unscented litter, or one whose listing says no perfumes or fragrances are added; 4 for a scented litter. A scented litter does not score 0 because the dvm360 review says the impact of fragrance on cats' litter preference is unclear, but it loses most of the credit because AAFP/ISFM says cats often find aromatic litter offensive. Where a listing contradicts itself on scent, the title and bullets are used and the contradiction is printed on the card.
Dust
15%Scoring: 10 for a published dust-free figure of 99% or higher on the listing; 7 for a low-dust claim with no figure. Every dust figure on this page is the maker's own claim, not a measurement.
Odor Mechanism
15%Scoring: 10 for activated carbon or activated charcoal named on the listing, the one additive the dvm360 review says cats preferred in a study; 8 for another named mechanism (baking soda with odor eliminators, starches and enzymes, a plant-derived ingredient, silica gel absorption); 6 for an odor claim with no named mechanism. The dvm360 review's author disclosed research funding from The Clorox Company, so the activated-carbon credit is limited to this one factor.
Tracking
15%Scoring: 10 when the listing states low tracking; 5 when tracking is not addressed, or when the maker warns that the litter may track. Where a maker gives two different statements, the more cautious one is used. Price is not scored. The per-factor scores for every pick are printed in the comparison table, so each total can be recomputed; totals are rounded to one decimal, with halves rounded up.
See all score methodologies on the Gear Score index.