PetPalHQ

Gear Score Methodology

PetPal Gear Score

Best Aquarium UV Sterilizers (2026)

View full buying guide →

Editorial synthesis of manufacturer specifications (Aqua Ultraviolet, Coralife, AA Aquarium) and aquarist education from Bulk Reef Supply — no first-hand product testing. The Clear-Water UV Score is a composite of published specs and expert/hobbyist consensus, not a measurement. PetPalHQ does not run a testing lab. Ranks reflect each pick's best-fit use case — tank size, form factor, and budget — rather than raw score order, so a lower-ranked pick can carry a higher score. The score rates UV effectiveness for class, build quality, ease of use, and value within a pick's intended size band. Value is one explicitly weighted factor of the score, and it is the smallest weight, so a higher rank never means a higher score and value only breaks ties.

Clear-Water UV Score = (UV Effectiveness × 0.35) + (Build Quality & Components × 0.25) + (Ease of Use & Setup × 0.20) + (Bulb & Maintenance × 0.12) + (Value × 0.08)

Factor breakdown

UV Effectiveness

35%

How well the unit delivers a useful UV dose to the water for its class — a function of wattage, the flow rate it is designed for, and dose transparency. We synthesize this from manufacturer specs (wattage, gallon ratings, published flow-versus-dose figures where available) and from Bulk Reef Supply's framing that UV dose depends on flow rate and only affects organisms that pass through the chamber. The Clear-Water UV Score is a composite of published specs and expert consensus, not a measurement — PetPalHQ does not run a testing lab.

Build Quality & Components

25%

Quality and durability of the chamber, lamp protection, bracket, and fittings. We credit quartz sleeves and sealed-bulb designs, durable pond-grade bodies, hang-on or in-line mounting flexibility, indicator lights, and safety certification such as UL listing where documented.

Ease of Use & Setup

20%

How easy the unit is to install and run. We reward all-in-one internal units that need no plumbing and tool-free installation, and we weigh whether a canister requires a separate pump and inline plumbing against the dose control that separate pump enables.

Bulb & Maintenance

12%

Living with the lamp over time — replacement intervals, the fact that UV-C output fades long before the bulb stops glowing, and any indicator that flags status. We reward designs that make bulb changes painless and ratings that account for end-of-life output, since the most common owner failure is running a spent lamp.

Value

8%

Purchase price relative to capability and the longer-run cost of replacement bulbs. This is the smallest weight in the score by design, so a strong-value pick never outranks a more effective unit on the score alone — value breaks ties, it does not drive the ranking, and rank here reflects best-fit use case rather than score order.

Read the full guide →

See all score methodologies on the Gear Score index.